After many months of uncertainty, the Indonesian government has announced an easing of the nickel ore ban, which was introduced back in 2014.
We believe that the announcement has the following implications:
- Smelter project investors will be put off by the announcement, resulting in a slowdown in investment in additional capacity.
- Ore prices will be under downward pressure and in a lower ore price environment we assess that Chinese NPI RKEF producers will see cost benefits as a result.
- Indonesian ore will displace some ore exports from the Philippines and New Caledonia.
On January 12, 2017, Indonesia introduced new mining regulations that allow the export of low grade nickel ore - defined as having <1.7% nickel content - once certain conditions have been met.
As we understand it, the regulations stipulate the following:
- Nickel miners who have allocated at least 30% of their smelting capacity for processing low-grade ore will be allowed to export any excess low-grade nickel ore.
- Exports are permitted for a period of five years from the date of the regulation.
- Permission to export will be granted by the government to companies that meet a number of conditions including a commitment to build a smelter within five years.
- Exports of nickel ore will be subject to a maximum 10% export tax, depending on the progress made in building a smelter.
- Foreign partners in smelter projects are required to divest their share of ownership to their local partners in stages after five years of production with the local partner's share reaching 51% by the 10th year of production. The following table shows the stages of divestment after 5 years of production
Implications for further investment in NPI capacity
The relaxation of the ore ban comes as a surprise as the policy itself has been successful. Revenue from ore exports at their peak in 2013 is reported to be around $1.7bn. To achieve the same level of revenue, at a nickel price of $10,000/t, around 170,000 tpy of NPI production would have been required. Prior to the announcement our forecast for Indonesian NPI this year exceeded this level and we were expecting additional growth beyond 2017. However, the relaxation is likely to slow investment in additional capacity and we will explore this in more detail in our forthcoming Nickel Market Outlook, due to be published at the end of this month.
The ban was introduced to promote investment in Indonesia's downstream production capacity domestically. This strategy was finally starting to bear fruit. Since the ban was introduced there has been a raft of NPI (nickel pig iron) projects announced, some of which have already come on stream including:
- Tsingshan's PT Sulawesi, the largest producer of NPI in Indonesia, which is in the middle of expanding capacity to 150,000 tpy from 90,000 tpy;
- PT Megah Surya Pertiwi (PT MSP) - a joint venture between Xinxing Ductile Iron Pipes and Harita Group - started NPI production in October 2016 and currently has three RKEF lines in Indonesia with an annual capacity of 19,000 tonnes of nickel
Virtue Dragon is expected to commission its NPI project this year. The first phase was expected to have a capacity of 60,000 tpy but we understand that this could be scaled back to 30,000 tpy. This along with the commissioning of Tsingshan's expansion is expected to boost Indonesian NPI to 169,000 tonnes this year. However, at present it is hard to see companies looking to invest in additional NPI capacity in Indonesia and there is a greater risk surrounding the viability of blast furnace operations in the country. Our Nickel Cost Model estimates that the average Business cost at an average Indonesian blast furnace (BF) operation is around $16,000/t, which is twice the cost of an RKEF operation.
Implications for the ore price and costs at Chinese NPI producers
The relaxation of the ore ban will put downward pressure ore prices from current levels. At the time of writing, medium-grade nickel ore (1.5% nickel) was trading at RMB 380/t ($55/t). Additionally, the cost structure of Chinese RKEF producers is likely to be reduced.
In assessing the impact of the relaxed ore ban on NPI costs at Chinese RKEF operations, we consider an average operation in Jiangsu province using 1.5% nickel ore to produce 10% grade NPI. The Prices used in the base case are the average values for December 2016. We then determined costs under the following three scenarios:
1. A $10/t fall in ore price
2. A $20/t fall in ore price
3. Use of higher nickel grade at 1.6%
The results of the scenarios are presented in the table below.
Under all scenarios considered, Chinese RKEF producers are likely to see a cost benefit from the relaxation of the Indonesian ore ban. Scenarios 1 and 2 show that costs would be lowered by around $970/t for every $10/t fall in the ore price. Meanwhile, in Scenario 3 the use of a higher grade ore (1.6%) would require paying a higher price relative to using 1.5% ore. Despite the higher ore price, costs would be lowered by around $200/t due to improvements in smelter efficiency by using a higher ore grade. Consequently, a lower production cost at Chinese NPI plants will also have a positive impact on Chinese stainless steel producers. Moreover, we could also see Chinese NPI production rising on the availability of additional ore.
Implications for Philippines and New Caledonia ore exports
Finally, one of the big questions at the moment is: how much ore will be exported annually? At present the answer to this question isn't clear as there are no references to an upper limit on annual ore export volumes. However prior to ban, China was the largest importer of Indonesian nickel ore. The Philippines became the main source for ore in the absence of Indonesia. However, now that the ban has been relaxed, we expect that China will once again be looking to secure material from Indonesia.
The relaxation of the Indonesian ore ban has meant that developments in the Philippines have taken a back seat for now. Moreover, there is a possibility of miners choosing to reduce exports again if nickel ore prices decline to levels seen in the early part of 2016.
A decline in nickel ore prices is also likely to weaken the economics of exporting ore from New Caledonia. At the end of December, the government of New Caledonia granted three companies the right to export nickel ore to China. Export permits have been granted to Societe Le Nickel (SLN), Groupe Ballande's Societe des Mines des Tontouta (SMT) and Societe Mai Kouaoua Mines (MKM), which will allow these mines to sell nickel ore totalling 1.95 million WMT annually to Chinese Customers. On a nickel content basis this equals around 17,000 tonnes.Explore this topic with CRU
When we last looked at the IMO 2020 MARPOL Annex VI policy back in 2018 Q4, there were many sources of ambiguity in terms of the outlook.